Industry News
Is it more effective to use a series of prompts to make Claude first act as five advisors and have them argue with each other before answering the question, rather than asking directly?
These past two days, a certain promotional message has been presented as “a major new feature from Claude” and has been spread everywhere. But let me dampen your enthusiasm right away: this isn’t actually a new feature at all; it’s just a command that was already included in the project documentation and can be used in any chat conversation.
The approach is indeed worth discussing. It requires the model to act as five different “advisers” before answering each question: The strategist considers what will best help you achieve your goals; the skeptic focuses on the weakest assumption among them; the creative advisor suggests an option you may not have considered; the representative of the target audience predicts how those affected by the decision will react; and the executor evaluates whether your available time and resources are sufficient to implement the plan.
Everyone should only say one or two things. Then, identify the point where there is the greatest disagreement, and have one of the participants address those strongest objections. Finally, reach a conclusion, determine what the first step should be, and clarify under what circumstances this suggestion may need to be adjusted.
There are two other rules that are crucial: assume that whatever needs to be highlighted must be clearly indicated; and if any missing information might potentially affect the outcome of a conclusion, ask you first.
Its strength lies in forcing the model to provide counterarguments. When you directly ask “Should I resign to start my own business?”, the model is likely to give an encouraging response that aligns with your tone. However, when there is a role specifically designed to challenge such assumptions, it becomes much less likely for the response to be one-sided.
The price paid for this is excessive bureaucracy. Just checking the exchange rate or correcting a spelling mistake requires holding meetings with five consultants—pure waste of time. A more reasonable approach would be to create a dedicated project for such purposes, using it only when decisions need to be made; for routine inquiries and answers, ordinary communication methods should still be used.