Industry News
The CEO of an AI tool for doctors valued at US$15 billion persuades medical students to go back to taking paper-based exams
The CEO of a medical AI company advises medical students to take more paper-based exams.
OpenEvidence CEO Daniel Nadler said at Semafor's Silicon Valley & The World Summit on Monday: "The risk of cognitive offloading is very, very acute." The so-called cognitive offloading is to hand over thinking to tools step by step until one's own ability slowly degrades.
His advice to medical students is that even if they are using AI at the same time, they should train and learn in traditional ways, take the difficult path, take paper-based exams, and take paper-based tests to make sure that they really know how to do it.
He believes those most at risk are young people who have grown up learning from AI.
These people have been learning with AI from the beginning, and may not have gone through the stage of hard-earning knowledge without the help of tools. This is exactly the advantage of paper-based exams: there are no external tools to rely on. If you can answer the question, you know it, and if you can’t answer it, you know you can’t.
This also falls on his own products. OpenEvidence is valued at US$15 billion and does exactly the same thing as AI for doctors, helping them summarize medical research. The more doctors rely on it to read literature and draw conclusions, the more likely they are to experience the kind of unloading he mentioned.
He’s not downplaying AI. He mentioned that all the company’s engineers are using “dozens of AI partners.”
Putting the two sentences together is not a contradiction. Engineers have the backbone of testing when writing code, and they can roll back if something goes wrong; doctors are dealing with patients, and they must first develop basic skills in their own minds before they can judge whether the answers given by the tools are reliable.