AI Card Bao AICARDBAO.COM

Industry News

Google presented American elementary and middle schools with a multiple-choice question: “Don’t use AI; also stop using search engines.”

Google has made its school policies for next year clear. Starting from early 2027, features such as Gemini, NotebookLM, Classroom Edition Gemini, and Google Search will all be disabled by default in the accounts of K-12 students. It will be up to school administrators to decide whether to re-enable these functions.

At this point, school districts might feel somewhat relieved. However, what comes next is far from reassuring.

Searching and artificial intelligence have become inseparable. If schools decide to completely ban the use of AI, students will not be able to use even basic search functions; all that will appear on the screen is a message stating that this service is unavailable. Chris Phillips, Vice President of Google Education, explained that searching and artificial intelligence have been so deeply integrated that it is impossible to separate them.

There are only two options available for schools: either use a comprehensive search function that includes AI assistance, or switch to the Guided Learning mode. In the latter case, the system detects when students are working on their homework and provides step-by-step guidance without directly giving them the answers. The third option—namely, using a traditional search bar without any AI features—is simply not available.

There are underlying reasons for this policy. In August of this year, Google automatically enabled the Gemini function in classrooms by default, which attracted widespread criticism from educators. In September, New York City prohibited students in the eighth grade and below from using generative AI during the current academic year, while the Los Angeles Unified School District also turned off all generative AI applications on school devices. After the two largest school districts in the United States expressed their opposition, Google decided to change its approach.

However, considering the dominant position of Chromebooks in American schools, if educators really decided to force the closure of search functions, libraries and teachers would have to adapt their teaching methods accordingly. Therefore, the phrase “right to make autonomous choices” seems a bit of a stretch when applied in this context.

Technically, it’s not impossible to implement such a feature, but I’m not quite convinced. A quick search on Google shows that in 2024, Google already added an option that allows users to view only web page links when searching. It’s entirely possible to create a search results page that displays only links. Not providing this option for schools seems more like a strategic decision related to the product development roadmap.

This month, the program will first be piloted in some schools in the United States. Google stated that more details regarding the implementation process will be provided in the coming months.

Related